Cybele’s Secret by Juliet Marillier: Book Review

I have an affiliate relationship with and Malaprop's Bookstore in beautiful Asheville, NC. I will earn a small commission at no additional cost to you if you purchase merchandise through links on my site. Read more on my affiliate page.
Cybele's Secret Book Cover

4 Stars

Paula is accompanying her father to Constantinople on a trading trip. She might “only” be a seventeen-year-old girl, but she’s an intelligent, able assistant. They’re in search of an ancient religious artifact, Cybele’s Gift. Once in Constantinople, Paula starts seeing strange visions, visions that she feels sure are coming from the Other Kingdom, the fairy tale world next to ours. She learns that it’s her turn to go on a quest. Can she accomplish the task set for her?

I am so torn in rating this book. The beginning felt like it was at least a hundred pages too long. I don’t know exactly what could have been cut, I’m just left with the feeling that a lot of it was unnecessary. It was all character development and setup for the quest, but it got a little boring and I was feeling disappointed that this wasn’t as good as Wildwood Dancing. It was interesting to read the descriptions of Constantinople, but there should be a limit to setup. I read 200 pages before I really got into it, but once the story got going, it was a fantastic fairy tale with impossible challenges, riddles, dangerous pursuit, and all the stuff that make us love the old stories. I finished the rest in one sitting, on the edge of my seat, waiting to find out what happened next. Three stars for the first half, five stars for the second half, and we’ll average it out at four.

Paula is a woman ahead of her time. She loves to read and dreams of opening her own book trading business. She sometimes gets a little too lost in her own head though, and needs to be reminded that there is a whole real life to be lived outside of books. She also has a temper that gets her in trouble a few times. It took me a little while to warm up to her, but in the end I liked her almost as much as her sister Jena.

Duarte the pirate is a dashing, charismatic figure, and I was never quite sure what to make of him. There are hidden layers to the man, and it was fun to watch Paula sounding him out. I kept picturing him as Iñigo Montoya.

And then there’s Stoyan. Oh, Stoyan, my love. He almost made me cry. The page got all blurry on me and everything. Do you know how it is killing me to admit that? I absolutely hate to cry, but he got to me. Captain Wentworth’s letter is the last word in romance from an eloquent lover, but Stoyan takes the cake for the blue collar guys. He’s tall and handsome of course, but he’s a wise, old, gentle soul. He can handle himself in a fight, but he ultimately knows what’s important in life and inadvertently reminds Paula of that frequently. He’s loyal, quiet, and willing to do anything for her. As Duarte says to him, “It is blindingly clear to me that you would jump through fire for her.” If you’ve ever read I Capture the Castle (which I recommend), Stoyan just might remind you of Stephen.

This is a “companion novel” to Wildwood Dancing. I don’t think it’s necessary to read them in any kind of order, but a small part of the plot from Wildwood will be spoiled if you read Cybele first.

I highly recommend this for fans of fairy tales, but you’ll have to have patience with the beginning. And be prepared to fall in love with Stoyan.

Other Posts You May Enjoy:


  1. I do think all of Juliet Marillier's books are kind of like that-slower in the beginning and then they take off. But I love them just the same. I really loved Cybele's Secret and I enjoyed it more than Wildwood Dancing. The setting and the mystery were very appealing to me.

  2. Misty and Aths, I'm pretty sure you'll both like it.

    I don't remember noticing that Daughter of the Forest started off slow, but I read that ages ago when it was first published. I remember liking the series as a whole though. Well, I haven't actually read the fourth one yet, but the first three anyway.

  3. Nice review. Isn't it really confusing when a book starts ok, and flows and ends fabulous? It gets really confusing to rate it.

    This one definitely sounds good. Fantasy and history and all. Some thing like my taste of books.

  4. I felt like that when I read Daughter of the Forest by Marillier: the beginning dragged and it felt like there was too much she had to cram in to get the story rolling; and then from there on out, it was fantastic. Something she needs to work on, I think. But she is really talented. I'll have to read this one sometime (and finish the Sevenwaters books, because I only read Daughter…, even though I'm told #2 is even better).

  5. When you mentioned it on Tuesday I went hunting for it and found it. Brand new:) I don't remember how I misplaced it or why I didn't bother to read it. It's looks good. Loved the review.

I love to hear from you! Please contact me (menu bar, above) if you're having trouble commenting.